Wrapping Up the Valiant Series Ivar Timewalker, re-reading from Book One thru to Book Three...
Sunday, February 26, 2017
Monday, February 20, 2017
Friday, February 17, 2017
John Byrne's Doomsday.1 #1-4
Another John Byrne reboot series which I rather enjoyed, mostly because of its single issue story format, each issue (of the four in a series) contains one full story of the survivors after doomsday.
Friday, February 10, 2017
John Byrne's Next Men #31-44
Yep, we're still on a John Byrne kick here, and this time I decided to re-read his 2010 continuation which was chopsocky and erratic but still retained the intrigue that the original series had.
Thursday, February 9, 2017
John Byrne's Trio #1-5
Well, we're still in a John Byrne kind of mood here, and so I thought I'd give his short-lived series TRIO another chance. Didn't like it at all the first time I read it,a nd even this time it was filled with Byrne redundancies, echoing stories from his Fantastic Four , X- Men and Alpha Flight runs.
Then I happened to read this essay by Doug Zawizsa on the CBR on forum, and realized I'd missed the point: this was SUPPOSED to be an OBVIOUS nod to his earlier creations!
From CBR:
A quick check of our solicits for this book revealed that it was being marketed thusly: “Fans of Byrne’s Fantastic Four and Alpha Flight especially, this is for you!” That is exactly what this book is: a remix of Fantastic Four and Alpha Flight with one of the goofiest basis for a comic team ever. Although they are initially referred to as Three, Two and One, the titular trio of this book is really Rock, Scissors and Paper.
Rock is an allegorical combo-deal of Thing and Puck, Scissors is a guy who can form supersharp metallic blades from his hands and Paper is a lady who is more reminiscent of Flatman from the Great Lakes Avengers than any other character (save possibly Byrne’s interpretation of Madame Rouge from the Doom Patrol). While Rock is fun in the same way both Puck and Thing are to their respective teams, this issue doesn’t give us enough revelation on either of his teammates save Scissors has a bit of a temper to go with the sharp blades at the ends of his arms. Hmmm. That seems familiar.
Byrne overwrites quite a bit through narration boxes, and in doing so also overuses the phrase “the next instant.” I’m not calling it lazy storytelling, mind you, but I would certainly expect more visual storytelling from an industry legend like John Byrne. The narration boxes seem like overly convenient shortcuts in some spots and unnecessary filler in others.
Byrne’s art is as good as it has been in recent years, rife with detail and filled with expressive characters. Some of the drawings are less about composition and storytelling as opposed to the cool shot, but if anything Byrne’s years of comic creating have earned him the right to have a little fun in his work. The coloring is on par with superheroics: lots of odd color combinations, like bad guys wearing green and purple together and metallic backgrounds soaked in various shades of blue.
Diehard John Byrne fans will absolutely adore this book as they’ll undoubtedly see it as an opportunity for Byrne to write and draw “Fantastic Four”-like stories without being burdened or restricted by a shared universe. Casual comic book fans unfamiliar with Byrne’s work might not see anything spectacular, while veteran readers looking for a retroactive title just might be pleasantly surprised.
“Trio” stands out on the new comic racks largely due to the fact that this, like his “Next Men,” is John Byrne doing what John Byrne wants to do. In a time of infinite crossovers and unnecessary reboots, John Byrne’s latest comic book is a twisted interpretation of previous works polished up to seem new. That apparent newness is enough to bring eyes to the book, but it might have to work on being legitimate newness in order to keep them here. I’ll be back for the next issue, but I honestly am uncertain if that’s because of the creator’s name on the book or the fact that this story actually interests me.
Then I happened to read this essay by Doug Zawizsa on the CBR on forum, and realized I'd missed the point: this was SUPPOSED to be an OBVIOUS nod to his earlier creations!
From CBR:
A quick check of our solicits for this book revealed that it was being marketed thusly: “Fans of Byrne’s Fantastic Four and Alpha Flight especially, this is for you!” That is exactly what this book is: a remix of Fantastic Four and Alpha Flight with one of the goofiest basis for a comic team ever. Although they are initially referred to as Three, Two and One, the titular trio of this book is really Rock, Scissors and Paper.
Rock is an allegorical combo-deal of Thing and Puck, Scissors is a guy who can form supersharp metallic blades from his hands and Paper is a lady who is more reminiscent of Flatman from the Great Lakes Avengers than any other character (save possibly Byrne’s interpretation of Madame Rouge from the Doom Patrol). While Rock is fun in the same way both Puck and Thing are to their respective teams, this issue doesn’t give us enough revelation on either of his teammates save Scissors has a bit of a temper to go with the sharp blades at the ends of his arms. Hmmm. That seems familiar.
Byrne overwrites quite a bit through narration boxes, and in doing so also overuses the phrase “the next instant.” I’m not calling it lazy storytelling, mind you, but I would certainly expect more visual storytelling from an industry legend like John Byrne. The narration boxes seem like overly convenient shortcuts in some spots and unnecessary filler in others.
Byrne’s art is as good as it has been in recent years, rife with detail and filled with expressive characters. Some of the drawings are less about composition and storytelling as opposed to the cool shot, but if anything Byrne’s years of comic creating have earned him the right to have a little fun in his work. The coloring is on par with superheroics: lots of odd color combinations, like bad guys wearing green and purple together and metallic backgrounds soaked in various shades of blue.
Diehard John Byrne fans will absolutely adore this book as they’ll undoubtedly see it as an opportunity for Byrne to write and draw “Fantastic Four”-like stories without being burdened or restricted by a shared universe. Casual comic book fans unfamiliar with Byrne’s work might not see anything spectacular, while veteran readers looking for a retroactive title just might be pleasantly surprised.
“Trio” stands out on the new comic racks largely due to the fact that this, like his “Next Men,” is John Byrne doing what John Byrne wants to do. In a time of infinite crossovers and unnecessary reboots, John Byrne’s latest comic book is a twisted interpretation of previous works polished up to seem new. That apparent newness is enough to bring eyes to the book, but it might have to work on being legitimate newness in order to keep them here. I’ll be back for the next issue, but I honestly am uncertain if that’s because of the creator’s name on the book or the fact that this story actually interests me.
John Byrne's Doom Patrol 1-18
John Byrne's doomed Doom Patrol reboot. Like most of his reboot stuff like Superman, Wonder Woman and OMAC, his tinkering with the originals must be taken with a grain of salt, but all of them (Wonder Woman aside, which I think is his worst effort) are good reads, comics that you want to read over and over again, and Doom Patrol was yet another satisfying re-read series.
Byrne has a real gift for storytelling!!!
Byrne has a real gift for storytelling!!!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)